Holiday gifts: shop the Gift Center and see our order-by dates. Free standard shipping on continental US orders over $99.

Cartoon white elephant in an orange scarf carrying a wrapped gift on green, the banner for white elephant puzzle gifts

Puzzle and Game White Elephant Gifts | Under $25

(49 products)

Bring a white elephant gift worth stealing. These wooden brain teasers, puzzle boxes, and quick-play games are made by our small family business, wrap small, and get passed around the room at office parties, Yankee Swaps, and Dirty Santa exchanges. Every pick here starts at $25 or less, and most can be personalized with laser engraving. Choose an easy icebreaker or a clever challenge and let the stealing begin.

Shop Trending Puzzle and Game Collections
View as
Fred the Cat sitting on a wooden box at the Creative Crafthouse workshop.

Fred the Shop Cat

Say hi to Fred! He is the fuzziest and cutest member of the Creative Crafthouse Family.

Popular Collections

View all

Wooden puzzles and games for office parties, Yankee Swaps, and Dirty Santa

White Elephant Gifts Made by Our Small Family Business

Made by our small family business. Creative Crafthouse is a family-run business that has been designing and making wooden puzzles, games, and brain teasers since 2003, and every order ships from our Florida shop. We picked these with gift exchanges in mind: easy to wrap, fun to pass around, and worth stealing.

Make it personal. Most of these can be laser engraved with a name or short message. See our custom laser engraving.

A quick party game. For fast laughs and easy rules, bring a Penny Drop dice game. Shop the Penny Drop Game.

Giving cash or a gift card? Hide it inside a wooden puzzle box. Shop gift card and money puzzle boxes.

Need a stocking stuffer too? Browse our stocking stuffers.

Need help choosing? Tell us about your gift exchange and your price limit, and we will point you to a good pick.
Back to top