Puzzle and Game Christmas Gifts

(479 products)

Looking for a Christmas puzzle gift? Match the gift to how they like to play. Choose the Authentic Penny Drop Game Set for family game night, Tangram Challenge Plus for a shape-puzzle fan, Cash Out when giving cash or a gift card, Crossroads for a stocking stuffer under $10, or The Devils Square for an experienced solver.

Every item in the Creative Crafthouse shop can be personalized. Use the filters below to compare gift sets, budgets, ages, and challenge levels. For a shorter decision guide, read our 2026 Christmas puzzle gift picks.

Creative Crafthouse
Personalized Tabletop Cornhole Game | Handcrafted Wooden Mini Set with 8 Bags

Regular price$36.95

View details
Creative Crafthouse
Banker Puzzle | Personalizable Gift

(2)

Regular price$40.25

View details
$Secret Sum Puzzle | Math and Logic Brain Teaser - Creative Crafthouse$ $Secret Sum Puzzle | Math and Logic Brain Teaser - Creative Crafthouse$

Creative Crafthouse
Secret Sum Puzzle | Math and Logic Brain Teaser

(1)

Regular price$55.95

View details
$Star 26 Math Brain Teaser - Every row on the star must add to 26 - Creative Crafthouse$ $Star 26 Math Brain Teaser - Every row on the star must add to 26 - Creative Crafthouse$

Creative Crafthouse
Star 26 Wooden Puzzle | Math Logic Brain Teaser

(11)

Regular price$14.95

View details
Creative Crafthouse
Brilliant England Wood Puzzle | UK Themed Brain Teaser Gift

Regular price$34.95

View details
Creative Crafthouse
Animals of the Appalachian Mountains Wood Puzzle | Handmade Gift

(11)

Regular price$35.95

View details
$Sum 15 Game - Alternate turns to be first to add to 15. Fun with Math for younger crowd - Creative Crafthouse$ $Sum 15 Game - Alternate turns to be first to add to 15. Fun with Math for younger crowd - Creative Crafthouse$

Creative Crafthouse
Sum 15 Game | Educational Montessori STEM Math Game for Kids

(2)

Regular price$15.49

View details
Creative Crafthouse
Mexican Train California Edition | Hub and Tokens Wooden Domino Game

Regular price$21.49

View details
Creative Crafthouse
Double Trouble Bowling String Puzzle | Party Favor

(3)

Regular price$10.95

View details
Creative Crafthouse
Medical Assistant Wood Puzzle | Personalizable Gift

Regular price$37.95

View details

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes a good Christmas puzzle gift for an adult?

Choose by how much challenge the recipient enjoys. Browse puzzles and games for adults for a broad selection, or start with our expert wooden puzzles for an experienced solver.

Can every Christmas puzzle gift be personalized?

Yes. Every item in the Creative Crafthouse shop can be customized. Add a name or short message on the product page. For a particular placement, image, logo, or longer message, request custom work.

What Christmas puzzle gifts work for a stocking or small exchange?

Start with our Puzzle and Game Stocking Stuffers collection. The Puzzle and Game Stocking Stuffers collection keeps the choice focused on compact puzzles and games for stockings, office exchanges, and add-on gifts.

How can I make cash or a gift card more fun to open?

Use a wooden gift-card or money puzzle box. The recipient solves the box before reaching the gift, so the container becomes part of the exchange. Compare our gift-card and money puzzle boxes.

Where should I start if I am not sure which puzzle to choose?

Read our 2026 Christmas puzzle gift guide for seven picks organized by recipient, challenge, and budget. Use this collection when you want to compare the wider catalog.